Are you looking for a jet black liner for your waterline? Something that stays put all day? Well this is what I recommend...Inglot's AMC Eyeliner Gel. It has been my fave for years and is the only liner, so far, that does not come off. It is the blackest black(if that makes sense). I use an angle brush to apply it and I also use it with lashes(to mask the lash strip). There are many colors to choose from! You can purchase it at any Inglot store, Macy's, and online www.inglotcosmetics.com 😉